The Football Expert


Home
NFL Draft
Fantasy Football
NFL Analysis
College Football
Mock Draft Database
Columns
Contacts
Links
Forums Radio Twitter
CBS Fantasy Football


Six Players to Avoid
by Paul Eide
Fantasy Football Director
9/6/09


Frank Gore, San Francisco
The emergence of Glen Coffee is part of it, but Gore hasn’t played a full season in two years while his carries, receptions and total yards have decreased in each of the last three years, meaning he is definitely trending downwards. Having torn the ACL’s in both knees and the labrum in both shoulder’s he is primed for a career ender at any moment. Don’t believe me? Draft him, watch the way he runs and cringe all season as your blood pressure reaches dangerously high levels.

Brandon Marshall, Denver
Where do I start? I’ve actually been at drafts where owners are selecting this guy in the fourth round and earlier and are happy about it. Why would you draft someone that high on the thought that once he gets traded he will explode? The Broncos have said they aren’t trading him, and a guy with his mental makeup could go AWOL at any moment, screwing you as a fantasy owner big time. Wouldn’t you prefer a guy with less sex appeal that will produce where he is now? Like TJ Housmandzadeh or even Wes Welker? Plus, neither of those guys are maniacs.

Maurice Jones-Drew, Jacksonville
Yeah, you heard me; avoid MJD. He has never taken more than 200 carries in anyone single season, durability is a huge concern, as he simply is not big enough to be an every down back in the NFL. And yes, he may catch 50+ passes as a receiver but who cares if he isn’t productive carrying the ball? You may as well over pay for Leon Washington if receiving RB’s get your juices flowing. Jones-Drew no longer has the luxury of sneaking up on anyone as well; opposing defenses are now gearing up to stop him specifically. MJD had two games of over 100 yards rushing in 2008, and one game with over 100 yards receiving, and after five games in 2008 the “bust” word was being thrown around quite liberally. Remember that, Fantasy pundits? I do. #1 overall selection ahead of Adrian Peterson? What?? One rushing TD in final five games of 2008.

Marques Colston, New Orleans
Remember what happened after former Panthers RB Stephen Davis had micro fracture knee surgery? Yeah, me neither. So why is more not being made of this anything but “minor” offseason surgery? In addition Colston also had midseason thumb surgery last year, which may have explained the number of drops in the games he was healthy. Colston gave fantasy owners nothing but headaches in 2008, and ultimately gave way to Lance Moore as the Saints #1 WR. Avoid the Noid.

Roy Williams, Dallas
19 catches in 10 games. That’s all this former stud WR could muster after a trade between the Lions and Cowboys brought him to Dallas last season. In an offense where he should have emerged, as he was finally not constantly double teamed thanks to the presence of TO and Jason Witten, Williams disintegrated from a fantasy standpoint, producing less that Patrick Crayton and Martellus Bennett.  The experts have him on par with other WR’s like TJ Housmandzadeh and DeSean Jackson, but don’t buy the hype.

Dustin Keller, New York Jets
Why is he rated higher than John Carlson or Owen Daniels everywhere I look? No one benefited more than Keller from arrival of Brett Favre last year, as Favre has always made the tight end statistically productive, and with his departure no one suffers more. And sure Mark Sanchez has looked solid in limited duty, but selecting Keller to be a starter bar none has “bad idea” written all over it.