2008
NFL Mock
Draft - 7 Rounds
by Gregory Cox
Director of College
Football and NFL Analysis
4/25/08
Round 3
64) Miami – OG Chilo Rachal
(USC)
The Dolphins need serious renovations on the offensive line. Justin
Smiley
(guard) was brought in from San
Francisco to hold down one
spot. For as many needs as they have this is probably
their best combination of need and value. He could be the final piece
to their
starting line puzzle.
65) St. Louis
– WR Andre
Caldwell (Florida)
Most people wouldn’t
expect the Rams to need a wide
receiver, especially with pass happy offensive coordinator Mike Martz
long
gone. However, their top two receivers will be 30 when the season
starts and
tight end Randy Michael will be 29. The time to breed a replacement isn’t
when these guys are all 32+ years old. Bruce was cut and signed with
rival San Francisco. If Arizona, Seattle and San Francisco weren’t
thinking of adding a
corner they will be after this pick. Plus, they can reunite the Caldwell
brothers.
66) Kansas
City – DT Pat Sims (Auburn)
Their run defense is poor. Backup James Reed was released and Turk
McBride, one
of two tackles drafted last year, is being used outside at end. By all
accounts
Sims should not be on the board at this point and they will snatch him
up.
67) Carolina (via NY Jets) –
SS/FS Thomas DeCoud (California)
Someone needs to play free safety on this team. They signed Terrence
Holt, but
he’s
best known for being the brother of a stud wide receiver. At best
DeCoud is a
future starter, at worst he’s a versatile backup with special teams
value.
68) Atlanta – TE Fred Davis (USC)
They signed Ben Hartsock to “replace”
star Alge Crumpler.
The good news is that he set career highs in receptions and yards last
year.
The bad news is that he caught 12 passes for 138 yards and in four pro
seasons
hasn’t
scored once. Davis was very productive in his senior year with three games over
110 yards
while leading the Trojans in receiving overall following the departures
of
Steve Smith and Dwayne Jarrett. His value dips a little because he
won’t give
much of anything in the blocking department and there are questions
about his
ability to be coached at the pro level. The Falcons take the value.
69) New England (via Oakland) – WR Jordy Nelson
(Kansas State)
This is going to be one of those picks that will make their opponents
cringe.
They aren’t
in a bad situation at wide receiver after retaining Randy Moss and
Jabar Gaffney,
but Donte’
Stallworth has left for Cleveland. Former second round pick Chad Jackson is looking like a
bust at this
point. If they want to keep up their high octane attack an addition
could
happen. By the way, is it not amazing that last year Tom Brady had five
more
touchdown passes than Minnesota, Miami, Buffalo and Tennessee combined? Nelson has great athleticism
as a former high school track star and is coming off a monster senior
season.
He has some toughness and is a decent blocker. Many have compared him
to
current Patriot Wes Welker, but with a bigger frame.
70) Chicago (via San
Francisco) – ILB/OLB Tavares
Gooden (Miami, FL)
Most of this draft will be focused on their offense and for good
reason. I
think it is smart business to grab an extra linebacker just in case.
I’m not
saying the rumors of Urlacher retiring are true and they did just lock
up Lance
Briggs, but they don’t want to be caught short handed if an injury
occurs.
Gooden has versatility and was athletic enough in high school to throw
a discus
nearly 200 feet, finishing among the nation’s top 10.
71) Jacksonville (via Buffalo/Baltimore) – SS Josh
Barrett (Arizona State)
Their
defense has been
their heart and soul. Sammy Knight was fantastic this season, but he’s
gone to the Big Apple. Gerald Sensabaugh played 2 games last year
before
hitting injured reserve. He was signed to a one year deal. They took
Reggie
Nelson (Florida) last year and need a solid player to
pair him with. Barrett is a good fit. It is amazing that a player his
size (nearly
6’2” and over 220) can run the 40 in the mid 4.3s.
72) Buffalo – TE Brad Cottam
(Tennessee)
The tragic injury to Kevin Everett has created a hole and not to be
insensitive
but honestly they would have needed a tight end anyway. Now they’re
desperate
after signing Teyo Johnson, a second round bust with Oakland who
caught 26 passes over three seasons
from 2003-2005. Then they went back to the Raiders for a player so good
(Courtney Anderson) the struggling Silver & Black dumped him on Detroit and Atlanta where he
played 4 games last year
without catching a pass. Did they learn nothing from watching Doug
Jolley waste
away with the Jets after he was traded there from Oakland?
Somewhere Rickey Dudley is working on
his comeback and hoping the Bills give him a look. As a team Buffalo had just
12 TD passes all year. Robert
Royal and Michael Gaines were both part of the passing game, but now
Gaines is
gone to Detroit and another threat would upgrade their
offense. Cottam can be an imposing threat. He was a star at the combine
checking in at 6’7” and 271 pounds while
running a 4.68 in
the 40. He also shined at his pro day and seems to have done enough to
overcome
his “injury
history”
tag with great athleticism, but it could still wind up dropping him on
draft weekend.
The Bills have to love his height given their small receivers.
73) Kansas
City (via
Denver/Minnesota) –
C Mike Pollak (Arizona State)
This trade of Jared Allen is looking better all the time. Now the
Chiefs wind
up with the top center. They are overhauling their offensive line in a
big way
and Casey Wiegemann will be allowed to leave in free agency as part of
their
youth movement. Pollak showed well at the combine including a quick 40
(4.99)
and was stronger than most anticipated. He looks like the clear cut top
center
prospect and might not even last this long.
74) Carolina – RB Kevin Smith (Central Florida)
DeAngelo Williams has carried the ball only 121 and 144 times in two
seasons.
Out of 29 games as a pro he has just three games with more than 17
carries and
with DeShaun Foster gone to San
Francisco someone has to
help him share the load. I don’t know if they can risk
waiting too long for a player in that role given their emphasis on the
running
game. In Smith they get someone who carried the ball an astounding 450
times as
a senior in 14 games, a number that would extrapolate to 514 NFL
carries or
about 25% more than the all-time single season record. He would be a
great
addition to the offense.
75) San
Francisco (via Chicago) – OG Roy Schuening (Oregon State)
The offensive line that paved the way for Frank Gore’s 1,695 rushing yards
in 2006 had their share of problems this year. Gore’s average rush dropped
from 5.4 to 4.2 although some of that can be attributed to his health.
Justin
Smiley is gone to Miami and Larry Allen (36) has all but retired.
76) Detroit – OLB Shawn
Crable (Michigan)
Two starting linebackers (Lehman and Bailey) left in free agency. Lone
returning starter Ernie Sims has been a tackling machine in his two
years with
the team, but the same can’t be said on the other side. It never
hurts to bring in a local Wolverine.
77) Cincinnati – RB Matt Forte
(Tulane)
The
Bengals have enough
picks to get pretty creative in this draft. When value meets a need
they have
to strike. Their luck with running backs is almost as bad as it is with
linebackers. Kenny Watson has no business leading this team in rushing.
Rudi
Johnson might be wearing down and recent picks Chris Perry and Kenny
Irons have
serious injury clouds hanging over their head. Forte adds the ability
to catch
passes. He had 103 receptions for 985 yards in 43 games, not to mention
his
2,127 yards rushing as a senior with 23 touchdowns.
78) New
Orleans – DT Marcus
Harrison (Arkansas)
They need to toughen up the middle of their defensive line. Even if
Brian Young
was also retained he’ll turn 31 in July while Hollis Thomas is
33. Harrison’s character is an issue, and with such a
recent transgression I have struggled to determine when teams will take
a
chance. Many believe he’s a second round prospect. I would think the
fourth
round is appropriate and ultimately I split the difference.
79) Houston –
DE Jason Jones (Eastern Michigan)
The Texans are looking for someone to add as a bookend to former #1
overall
pick Mario Williams, a guy many once thought would be the NFL’s
version of Sam Bowie although it has not turned out that way. In a pass
rush
happy draft Jones might not make it out of day one, but if he does they
can’t
pass on him.
80) Philadelphia – OT Duane Brown
(Virginia Tech)
There is some youth on the Eagle offensive line, but their starting
tackles are
into their 30’s.
William Thomas has gotten so old that
in 2006 he asked people to quit calling him by his nickname (Tra).
Donovan
McNabb was sacked 44 times and for a mobile quarterback that is a high
number.
It appears 2006 draft pick Winston Justice was a miss after a heavily
publicized drubbing at the hands of Osi Umenyiora.
81) Arizona – CB Antwaun
Molden (Eastern Kentucky)
The Cardinals had a pretty good defense statistically, but weren’t able
to
translate their yardage ranking (#17) into keeping teams from scoring
(#27).
Perhaps a pass defense that finished #28 can take a lot of that blame.
Opponents converted 40.1% on third down against them. Antrel Rolle is
moving
into the spot vacated at free safety when Terrence Holt was cut meaning
multiple additions are likely in this draft. Molden is a fast rising
prospect.
82) Kansas
City (via Minnesota)
– OT/OG John Greco (Toledo)
The offensive line makeover continues. It is their biggest problem and
gets the
most attention in a draft bolstered by the Jared Allen trade. With the
tragic
passing of Heath Benedict, Greco moves up a bit as one of the better
versatile
offensive linemen in this draft. He was a tackle in college and could
shift
inside.
83) Tampa Bay –RB Ray Rice (Rutgers)
It’s
a nice story to bring back Warrick Dunn and Carnell Williams is still
in play
for this season, but I look for them to seek a mid-round addition for
insurance
at running back. At an even 5’8” Rice
might not at first glance appear as
someone able to wear down a defense or carry a big load. However, he
had 335
and 380 rushes over the past two seasons for the Scarlet Knights for an
average
of 27.5 per game and 5.32 yards per rush. He could be another Maurice
Jones-Drew who also plays in the Sunshine State.
Although projected as high as the end
of day one his height might ultimately cause him to drop down the board
with
many other capable players at the position who don’t have that limitation.
84) Washington
– OLB Xavier
Adibi (Virginia Tech)
London Fletcher is a tackling machine having topped 119 eight seasons
in a row
spanning three different teams. However, he’ll turn 33 this spring
and the time to replace him is before he collapses at midfield from
exhaustion.
The man has 1,229 career tackles for crying out loud. By midseason
Randall
Godfrey will be 35 and Marcus Washington 31 meaning they have to add
some youth
at linebacker to team up with Rocky McIntosh and H.B. Blades from the
past two
drafts. Adibi winds up getting dragged down the draft board by his lack
of
size, but on an active Hokie defense he consistently added a couple
sacks and
interceptions per season with his tackle numbers going up each year.
85) Tennessee
– CB Terrell Thomas (USC)
The Titans have to address replacing Adam Jones long term, especially
if
Reynaldo Hill leaves in free agency. Nick Harper was just a knee jerk
reaction
to the Jones suspension, and will turn 34 by the start of the season.
One
backup Herndon couldn’t work his way up the depth chart and was
cut. A bright spot has been Finnegan, a seventh round gem from 2006.
86) Seattle –
WR Mario Manningham (Michigan)
The Seahawks were a train wreck at wide receiver last year due in large
part to
injuries. How exactly did Hasselbeck throw for 3,966 yards? D.J.
Hackett is
gone to Carolina, Bobby Engram will be 36 by the end of
this season and Deion Branch is always hurt. Manningham had an
extremely
productive senior year with 7 games over 100 yards including a stretch
of six
in a row during Big Ten play averaging 7.2 receptions for 130.5 yards
with 10
total touchdowns. He ran a slow 40 (4.6 range) at the combine which
could hurt
his stock a little bit, but improved at his pro day. Lying to scouts
and then
later admitting it isn’t exactly going to boost his stock either. This
is a big
drop for him, but it’s a chain reaction. There are other good players
who teams
will turn to, coupled with the receiver needy teams who take him off
their
board and suddenly here he is.
87) Detroit (via Cleveland) – ILB Jonathan
Goff (Vanderbilt)
The heart of their defense has been missing a presence at middle
linebacker for
some time now and Teddy Lehman has left for Tampa Bay. Goff
ran a fast 40, fifth best at the
combine where he showed quickness and ability to cover a lot of ground
in the
drills.
88)
Pittsburgh – OG/OT Mike McGlynn (Pittsburgh)
They lost
Alan Faneca on the
heels of losing long time center Jeff Hartings to retirement prior to
the 2007
season which ended four decades of excellence for them at the position.
That
loss was addressed by signing Justin Hartwig off Carolina’s
scrap pile to compete with the disappointing Sean Mahan who now seems
to be a
center/guard backup. They signed Chris Kemoeatu to a one year deal
which likely
means they will seek competition for him in the draft. The versatile
hometown
guy is a perfect fit.
89) Jacksonville – DT Red Bryant (Texas
A&M)
This is a
nice value selection. Marcus Stroud has been
dealt to the Bills. The Jaguars need to start
stifling the run with regularity again. They replaced aging Grady
Jackson with
Jimmy Kennedy which has very little impact on their situation. Imagine
John
Henderson having a strong player next to him. I’m not sure Bryant falls
this
far but two of the other teams interested (Oakland, San Diego and Cleveland) don’t
have picks in the second or third round. They might be trading up to
acquire
him. Tearing his ACL in 2006 is one factor which could hold down his
value, but
it seems like every defensive tackle in this draft has some sort of
negative
issue in their closet.
90) Chicago (via San
Diego) – QB Andre’ Woodson (Kentucky)
Their quarterback play has been atrocious. When the defense and special
teams
stopped dominating the roof fell in. Griese was given his chance and
turned it
over multiple times in 4 of 6 extensive appearances. He has been dealt
to Tampa Bay. Grossman being invited back for a one
year contract is the equivalent of meeting a date for coffee. Not
exactly a
marriage proposal. Orton was given one last uneventful look and that
was smart.
Saying he’ll
compete for the starting job is comical. Woodson is worth this
investment. Some
are still fighting for his value in the third round, but there is
really no
buzz surrounding him whatsoever. His stock has dropped from middle of
round 1
to long term project and the word “terrible”
was uttered at his pro
day workout according to reports. I know he had some great games at Kentucky, but
some players can look like stars in
college and not project to the next level when the scouts break them
down. This
season they can mess around with Grossman and Orton while they figure
out what Woodson
can do.
91) Green Bay
– RB Steve Slaton (West
Virginia)
Ryan Grant saved their season at running back with 92.9 yards rushing
during
their final 10 games. After fumbling twice in the playoffs against Seattle he
plowed through the snow for 201
yards, but then the Giants shut him down to the tune of 13 carries for
29
yards. They didn’t have an alternative as no other back ran the ball in
the
game. Rookie Brandon Jackson was handed the job for the first two games
and
carried the ball 32 times for a paltry 75 yards (2.34 average). Vernand
Morency
seems like a backup and was given a one year deal to stick around until
someone
better puts him out of a job. Here he is. Slaton’s height (5’9”)
will limit his options as a pro in this running back rich draft.
However, he
had nearly 4,000 yards rushing for the Mountaineers in three seasons
and never
fewer than 18 total touchdowns.
92) Dallas –
FS Quentin Demps (UTEP)
The Cowboys have an extra first round pick and not a lot of team needs
which
allows them to make a luxury selection here. A lot of people feel Roy
Williams
is overrated although it is hard to argue with his 506 tackles in six
seasons
and 19 interceptions. Backup Keith Davis is gone so they need another
safety. Roy’s coverage skills are the problem and it
has been discussed that he will come out on obvious passing downs.
Enter Demps
who specializes in coverage.
93) Indianapolis – TE Craig Stevens
(California)
They love their tight ends and Ben Utecht left for Cincinnati.
Stevens impressed at the combine in the
40 (4.65) and by leading tight ends with 27 reps of 225 on the bench
press. If
he hadn’t
been playing with receivers DeSean Jackson, Lavelle Hawkins and Robert
Jordan
in college he would have caught a lot more passes.
94) New England – SS Craig Steltz (LSU)
There is
some
uncertainty at strong safety where Rodney Harrison is one more injury
from
retirement. Tank Williams was brought in for depth. Steltz hauled in 10
interceptions over his final 25 games for the reigning BCS champs. He
should
help them on special teams and eventually could start.
95) NY Giants
– WR Eddie
Royal (Virginia Tech)
New York
is a quality receiver short for when Toomer retires (soon) and in case
Burress
gets hurt. This year’s rookie Steve Smith looks like a keeper
while Sinorice Moss, well, not so much. Royal basically kicks him off
the
roster. He is similar in size/skills to DeSean Jackson (California)
with a cheaper price tag. Last year he
was one of the top punt returners in the FBS averaging 14.7 yards on 31
returns. Moss was great in that department in college, but hasn’t
returned a
single punt for the Giants. In 2007 veteran cornerback R.W. McQuarters
handled
all but one punt return, but had a long of 27 and an anemic average
(7.6).
96)
Washington (compensatory) – SS Tom Zbikowski
(Notre Dame)
When a player of Sean Taylor’s caliber dies it is impossible to
replace him on the field or off of it. I said in a previous version
that
selecting a player early (day one) might put undue pressure on that
player
trying to fill Taylor’s shoes. A former boxer, Zbikowski can deliver a hit.
97) Cincinnati (compensatory) – WR Lavelle
Hawkins (California)
On paper the Bengals have (or had) some of the best receivers in the
league.
Too bad the game isn’t played on an XBOX 360. I wrote “Chris
Henry always gets into trouble” weeks ago and now he has been cut two
more
incidents later. Chad Johnson is disgruntled and begging for a trade.
His
former Oregon State teammate T.J. Houshmandzadeh might be
their #1 going into the season. Doug Gabriel was a nice addition to the
depth
chart if he can keep his nose to the grindstone. At Cal Hawkins was
overshadowed by DeSean Jackson, but over the past two seasons was
fairly close
to him in production. With better play at quarterback I think he would
have
posted better numbers and he’ll certainly get that having Carson Palmer
throwing him the ball. Hawkins also returned 42 kickoffs last year for Cal so he adds
some special teams value.
98) Atlanta
(compensatory) – OT Tony Hills (Texas)
They have to hit the offensive line in this draft and now that a few
holes
elsewhere have been filled it is time for action. All three of their
passers
this past season suffered at least 6 sacks, 47 in all. Wayne Gandy is
probably
finished at age 37 and it’s tough to name even one other person on
their offensive line.
99) Baltimore
(compensatory) – OT Oniel Cousins
(UTEP)
Jonathan Ogden is as close to retirement as an active player can get.
Even if
he comes back for another season it is almost certainly his last. The
Ravens
also released long time center Mike Flynn meaning they must make
additions to
their offensive line. Their other primary needs are quarterback and
cornerback.
The talent available relative to pick value for both will be better
suited for
their next pick. One scenario they might consider is trading down to
the 9-12
range and taking quarterback Brian Brohm (Louisville).
|